Community Forum

Discuss common law, lawful rights, contracts, consent, and the principles explored across Lawful Truths Academy.

Respectful discussion Community learning Earn reputation

Contribution Badges

New MemberContributorScholarSenior ScholarMentor

Earn forum badges as you participate — start discussions, share replies, and collect likes to grow your reputation. Badges recognise your contributions and mark your expertise across the Lawful Truths community.

Natural Law

A law is enacted through proper procedure but is widely considered deeply unjust. Is it valid law?

Discussion in 'Natural Law' started by John, 24 Aug 2026.

Relevant eBook · Chapters 4 & 9

Understand the supreme law that sits above all statutes.

Explore Natural Law

Related eBooks

Magna Carta 1215 — 2x eBooks

Magna Carta 1215 — 2x eBooks

Original Magna Carta text and readable transcript.

$2.99

Start the conversation

This thread is a space for lawful, respectful discussion and shared learning.

What's your take on this — what experience or question can you share?

24 Aug 2026
J
JohnNew Member

Scenario: A legislature enacts a statute through entirely proper procedure. The statute is widely considered deeply unjust because it discriminates against a particular group. There is no higher constitutional provision that clearly prohibits it.

Question: Is this valid law? Would your answer differ depending on whether you approach the question from a natural law or legal positivist perspective? What role should moral reasoning play in determining legal validity?

0 votes
#1
Share

0 replies

No replies yet. Be the first to respond.

Please sign in to join the conversation.

Trending

Hot discussions right now

  1. 1

    Police stop Daniel while he's walking home and ask him to provide his name and address — is he required to provide them?

    Police Powers· 1
  2. 2

    A statute conflicts with a foundational constitutional principle — what would you examine?

    Constitutional· 0
  3. 3

    What does ubi jus ibi remedium actually mean in practice?

    Rights & Remedies· 0
  4. 4

    What is the difference between having a right and having an effective remedy?

    Rights & Remedies· 0
  5. 5

    Can someone acquire ownership rights through adverse possession?

    Land Law· 0

Related discussions

You might also like

Does law derive its authority from morality or from the institutions that enforce it?

Natural Law · 0 replies

Police stop Daniel while he's walking home and ask him to provide his name and address — is he required to provide them?

Police Powers · 0 replies

A statute conflicts with a foundational constitutional principle — what would you examine?

Constitutional · 0 replies

Can someone acquire ownership rights through adverse possession?

Land Law · 0 replies